Wednesday, September 17, 2008

2001: A Space Odyssey vs. There will be Blood Part 1

Both of these films have been highly regarded in consensus and there is no doubt that each of these films contribute heavily to the film knowledge base. Not only are these great films but the similiarities between these films are undeniable.

Structure is an important part of creating a coherent film that tells an interesting story. Both films open with creation. The creation of man is laid before us with a tribe of early man being taught how to use tools by a large monolith. In contrast Daniel Plainview already arrives on screen in full form and seems to be searching for his own monolith. Both segements are completely wordless and tell the story with pure visuals, which adds to the impact of these acts. In both films these opening scenes are the structure to all else that is built. Plainview uses oil from then on to establish power as does the apes that use the tools they discovered to retake the watering hole establishing the fact that the human race will on continue to conquer all that is in their way.

Perhaps I'm looking to into things but I do see alot of similiarties between the films and will continue this arguement later.

No comments: